Josh Klinghoffer talks touring with Pearl Jam, his relationship with the Red Hot Chili Peppers and his ambitious quest to make a solo album every year (2022)

Josh Klinghoffer talks touring with Pearl Jam, his relationship with the Red Hot Chili Peppers and his ambitious quest to make a solo album every year (1)

For those who thought we may see less of guitarist Josh Klinghoffer after his high-profile gig with the Red Hot Chili Peppers came to an end in 2019, you've been proven incorrect.

Post-Peppers, the multi-instrumentalist has been hard at work – launching his own solo band, Pluralone, and issued a pair of albums (2019’s To Be One with You and 2020’s I Don’t Feel Well). Plus, he's been enlisted as a hired hand for live work for both Pearl Jam and Eddie Vedder’s own band, the Earthlings.

Shortly after making his live debut with Pearl Jam and the Earthlings at the Ohana Festival and releasing two B-sides from Pluralone’s I Don’t Feel Well sessions (the tracks Across the Park and Sevens), Klinghoffer spoke to Guitar World.

What is your guitar setup with Pluralone?

“Honestly, Pluralone has only performed once live. So, I can give you the rundown of that rig. That was a particular, ‘thrown together at the last minute’ sort of setup for that one show. For any future shows, it’s ‘TBD’ – I haven’t really settled on a rig yet. But for the show at the Ohana Fest, I used… I think it’s a ’59 Gibson Barney Kessel that I just found a few months prior.

“And this is typical for me – for my first-ever show, I played a bunch of guitars that I was fairly unfamiliar with. I played a Teisco Del Ray 12-string that I had just purchased three days before. It had belonged to Ry Cooder. Those are the two guitars I used at that performance.

“I think I used my early ‘60s Vox AC30. It’s a tan one. And effects, I threw a 'board together for that show specifically, and I regretted it the entire time – because I played around four in the afternoon, and the sun was beating down on me, and I couldn’t see any of the lights! I was a little frazzled because it was my first performance, and I was forgetting all the things you’d normally check. So, I would play a whole song thinking I was on clean, but really, my distortion was on.

“And that distortion is one of my favorite pedals – an Ibanez [BS10] Bass Stack. And then the other thing I had up there but was putting a drum machine through it – but I use this on guitar all the time – was the Red Panda Particle.”

I usually approach everything thinking either, ‘Which Strat to use?’ or ‘Why would I not use a Strat?’

Which guitars did you use in the studio for Pluralone?

“I think because I spent so much time in the Chili Peppers, I was always attracted to the Strat. So, I usually approach everything thinking either, ‘Which Strat to use?’ or ‘Why would I not use a Strat?’ For Pluralone, I generally used a couple of different Strats on the last recordings. And I’ve recorded with a Jaguar and Jazzmaster. I tend to use a lot of Fenders in the studio.

“Apart from on this last Pluralone album I used my Gibson Firebird VII a little bit – which I got right when I joined the Chili Peppers, thinking I would tour with it a lot because it’s a lot of fun to play. But it wound up being difficult to find a place to play in that band. I used it on the first tour, but never again.

“I used a Fender Bass VI. The bass I used a lot on this album was my late friend’s Music Man StingRay fretless bass. He was my best friend growing up and he died when he was 19, so I used his bass on his birthday to record the song [The Report]. And I used an Ampeg AEB-1. And early ‘60s Jazz basses, too – I have one with flats and one with wounds.”

Josh Klinghoffer talks touring with Pearl Jam, his relationship with the Red Hot Chili Peppers and his ambitious quest to make a solo album every year (2)

How would you compare your Pluralone setup to what you used with the Chili Peppers?

“It’s a little smaller. The Chili Peppers live rig is one thing, and then the studio rig would be another thing. The last album I did with the Chili Peppers, The Getaway, I’m ashamed to admit that my rig was nothing like what I intended it to be. I did that whole album with a Marshall practice amp!

“But the two amps I had set up were a Marshall practice amp from the early ‘80s and a late ‘50s Fender Deluxe. I used the Marshall more. But I had a whole diametrically opposite plan for that record – I was going to do a lot of creative things with amps. I collected a bunch of amps during the first tour I’d done with them – it just goes to show you can’t make too many plans or try and control anything. So, I was going to put that into effect on my third album with them… which didn’t come to be.

“But live, it’s just louder and more present. I used a 200-watt Marshall Major amp – because John Frusciante used those, and at first, I was thinking, ‘If he used it, there’s got to be something to that loud amp.’ But over time and just the trend of how comfortable people are playing changed over time. So, I never played as loud as I think the band had in the past.

The fact that I used a 200-watt Marshall Major wound up being a problem… I should have used a smaller wattage amp

“The fact that I used that amp wound up being a problem. Probably because of all the headroom I had with that 200-watt amp and was always stacking different combinations of gain on top of each other. I should have used a smaller wattage amp. But the Marshall Major and the Fender Tone Master were my rig for the last tour.

“For 80 percent I’d use Strats. I had one Gibson on the first tour – the Firebird. And then the second tour it was an SG, and after that I had one Les Paul. I always had a 12-string of some kind – a Fender or a Firebird – because we would play Breaking the Girl once in a while that I’d do on 12-string. But pretty much always Strats. Once in a while, I’d bring out a Jazzmaster for fun. You can do a thousand things with a Strat.”

Have you been in touch with the Chili Peppers since your departure?

“Yeah, I have – in different amounts with different guys. I hadn’t seen Anthony [Kiedis] until the other day – I ran into him at Chad Smith’s birthday. But we text. I play Fantasy Basketball with Flea – he and I are in contact often. And then I’ve had the good fortune of just continuing to work with Chad a lot in the last two years – doing some records, and recording a lot with Andrew Watt.”

How did you get involved with Pearl Jam?

“The Chili Peppers and Pearl Jam have a long, intertwined history. The Chili Peppers took Pearl Jam out on one of their first tours back in 1991. Jack Irons – the original drummer of the Chili Peppers – connected Eddie with Stone [Gossard] and Jeff [Ament] in Seattle. And then Jack Irons went on to become the drummer in Pearl Jam for a little bit. Basically, the Chili Peppers and Pearl Jam have just been close.

“At some point, we connected. It was 2016 that I really saw them more – we did the same festival in New Orleans. We became a little closer over time – did some gigs with Mike McCready for various charities, and Eddie came down and played the benefit fundraiser for Flea’s music school in Silverlake.

“When their new album was going to come out – right before the pandemic – they felt they needed a little bit of help. Predominantly with background vocals and a couple other things. So, they had offered me the position of opening their tour and they said, ‘Since you’re there, you can sing a couple of bits, play percussion. Anything that’s needed.’

“As it turns out, I’m playing guitar on a song or two. I have a minor but key role at certain points of the show. But it’s really just through long history and friendships that existed before I was even around. But lucky for me I was a huge fan of them when I was a kid and I’m quite familiar with their older music. So, it’s not like joining some band that is just ‘another band.’

I don’t really play that much guitar in Pearl Jam. I play on four songs maybe at the most, and rarely will all four be in the same set

“For me, the friend that I mentioned whose fretless bass I played, he only owned a fretless because he was a big fan of Jeff Ament, and I was like, ‘You should get a fretless!’ I have a great picture of Jeff playing that bass that I sent to my friend’s mom – which is a really nice, full-circle moment.

“So, I wasn’t a stranger. It kind of made sense for me to join the Chili Peppers – when John decided not to do it at that period, I had been around for so long and friends toured with them, having me around wasn’t something that was an adjustment. Kind of the same with Pearl Jam. Not as much, maybe – because I didn’t know them as much, not living in Seattle. But having me around wouldn’t be that strange or different.”

How is it determined what you will be playing with Pearl Jam? As Eddie also plays a lot of guitar, there can potentially be four guitarists on stage.

“I don’t really play that much guitar. I play on four songs maybe at the most, and rarely will all four be in the same set. So, I’d say two or three a night. It has a lot to do with their latest album, Gigaton, was recorded over a long period of time and there were different sessions of overdubbing. So, there’s a lot of parts that might need a couple of extra hands.

“I’m never taking a guitar part that’s more essential than Stone or Mike. And Eddie plays guitar quite a bit in the band, but not as much on the newer stuff. He played a lot of guitar on the songs that he wrote, but he doesn’t play on those live. So, one of the ones I play on is a song where on the record there’s Eddie, Stone, and Mike playing. Eddie doesn’t want to play that song live, so I’m playing one of the little parts.”

Which songs do you play live with Pearl Jam?

“I play on Superblood Wolfmoon, Seven O’Clock – and that’s the one song where four of us are holding guitars at one point. But I honestly don’t think Eddie plays until the latter verse – right before the final chorus. So, when he starts playing, we almost crisscross. There might be one chorus where there’s four guitars at once.

“But then the minute the last chorus is over and the outro begins, I hand my guitar to my tech. I could just hold it, but I feel like I want there to be one less guitar. So then I just sing from that point on. I might be forgetting one, but I know I do a little part in In My Tree.”

I finally built a studio. For the first time in my life, I have the ability to record whenever I want

What's next on the cards for your solo material, and how long do you plan to tour with Pearl Jam?

“I have a slightly unrealistic/pompous bet with myself that I would be able to put out a record every year. So, I’m in year three of Pluralone’s existence, and I’m dangerously close to losing that bet and not having a record out this year. But the clock isn’t up yet. I’m trying to make as much music as possible under my own little solo moniker. And then whatever Pearl Jam has on the calendar.

“For the foreseeable future I’ll be with them, since it’s still in support of the Gigaton album. I’m by no means a member of Pearl Jam, but I’m definitely committed to touring this next cycle. They’ve been so welcoming, and they’re totally conscious and supportive of my music and my solo work.

“But I’ve been doing a lot of recording with friends, and like I said, with Andrew and Chad. There’s pretty much something going on every day. I finally built a studio. For the first time in my life, I have the ability to record whenever I want.”

  • Pluralone's latest album I Don't Feel Well (opens in new tab) is out now via ORG Music.

Josh Klinghoffer talks touring with Pearl Jam, his relationship with the Red Hot Chili Peppers and his ambitious quest to make a solo album every year (3)

Thank you for reading 5 articles this month*

Join now for unlimited access

US pricing $3.99 per month or $39.00 per year

UK pricing £2.99 per month or £29.00 per year

Europe pricing €3.49 per month or €34.00 per year

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Josh Klinghoffer talks touring with Pearl Jam, his relationship with the Red Hot Chili Peppers and his ambitious quest to make a solo album every year (4)

Join now for unlimited access

Prices from £2.99/$3.99/€3.49

Josh Klinghoffer talks touring with Pearl Jam, his relationship with the Red Hot Chili Peppers and his ambitious quest to make a solo album every year (5)

Greg Prato

Greg is a contributing writer at Guitar World. He has written for other outlets over the years, and has been lucky to interview some of his favorite all-time guitarists and bassists: Tony Iommi, Ace Frehley, Adrian Belew, Andy Summers, East Bay Ray, Billy Corgan, Alex Lifeson, Geddy Lee, Les Claypool, and Mike Watt, among others (and even took lessons from John Petrucci back in the summer of ’91!). He is the author of such books as Grunge Is Dead: The Oral History of Seattle Rock Music, Shredders: The Oral History of Speed Guitar (And More) and Touched by Magic: The Tommy Bolin Story.

FAQs

Are Josh Klinghoffer and John Frusciante friends? ›

Across the following years, Frusciante and Klinghoffer became extremely close, and collaborated on several projects, including four of Frusciante's solo albums and one fully collaborative release, 2005's A Sphere in the Heart of Silence.

What is Josh Klinghoffer doing? ›

Following his leave, Josh Klinghoffer has been predominantly focused on his other musical project, Pluralone. More recently, the musician toured with RHCP drummer Chad Smith once again, supporting Pearl Jam's Eddie Vedder on the tour for his latest solo album, Earthling.

Why is Josh Klinghoffer touring with Pearl Jam? ›

Later then, Klinghoffer has also mentioned his role in Pearl Jam. According to him, he has a key role as a member of the band. Saying that he was a huge fan of Pearl Jam when he was a kid, the guitarist added that he's familiar with their music. “As it turns out, I'm playing guitar on a song or two,” he reveals.

What guitar does Josh Klinghoffer? ›

What Guitars Does Josh Klinghoffer Play? Josh is primarily known for playing Fender Stratocaster guitars, the most notorious being his Black 1966 model, aka “Nero”. Also noteworthy are his Sunburst Strats as well as a 1966 Fender Telecaster that was gifted to him by John Frusciante.

Are Josh and John still friends? ›

Josh Klinghoffer has detailed his disintegrated relationship with former collaborator and fellow guitarist John Frusciante. While appearing on the Tuna on Toast With Stryker podcast, Klinghoffer described the friendship as “pretty non-existent,” adding that “it's been that way for 10 years.”

Did Josh Klinghoffer get fired? ›

Red Hot Chili Peppers bassist Flea recalled the emotions the group was dealing with when they fired the band's guitarist for a decade — Josh Klinghoffer — upon John Frusciante's return to the band.

How much money does John Frusciante make? ›

John Frusciante is an American guitarist, singer, songwriter and producer who has a net worth of $25 million. He is best known for being the guitarist of the rock band the Red Hot Chili Peppers.

What strings does Josh Klinghoffer use? ›

He uses D'Addario . 010 - . 046 on all of the guitars except the White Penguin, which is strung with . 011 - .

Does Frusciante play Josh Klinghoffer songs? ›

Frusciante has never played any of the band's songs with Navarro live, and he didn't play any Klinghoffer material at the band's recent return to the stage. Red Hot Chili Peppers are touring extensively in 2022.

Why did RHCP fire Josh? ›

The classic guitarist parted ways with the band for the second time after touring their Stadium Arcadium album and has since reunited with them, replacing Josh Klinghoffer in 2019. Now, speaking to Classic Rock, the Black Summer rocker has revealed he left the band over a decade ago due to being "off-balance mentally".

Who is Josh Klinghoffer replacing in Pearl Jam? ›

Klinghoffer joined RHCP in 2009 to replace the flighty John Frusciante, and was dismissed upon Frusciante's 2019 return to the group — a firing Klinghoffer said "truly felt like a death." (But would Klinghoffer's barber leak info about the new Chili Peppers album, though?)

Why did Frusciante leave RHCP? ›

Virtuoso guitarist John Frusciante left Red Hot Chili Peppers for the second time in 2009. He explained that he wasn't in the right place mentally, as he put it, he was an “imbalanced mess”. Thankfully, in 2019, Frusciante returned to the group after a ten-year break.

What pick Does Josh Klinghoffer use? ›

Dunlop Tortex Standard 0.60mm Guitar Picks

"Tortex . 60s picks. Again, that's what he's always used. I think John [Frusciante] used the same thing," says Josh Klinghoffer's guitar tech.

How rich is Anthony Kiedis? ›

Anthony Kiedis Net Worth
Net Worth:$155 Million
Date of Birth:Nov 1, 1962 (59 years old)
Gender:Male
Height:5 ft 8 in (1.75 m)
Profession:Songwriter, Actor, Singer-songwriter, Lyricist, Musician
1 more row

Who replaced John Frusciante? ›

Everybody loved Josh Klinghoffer, but it wasn't working out

“Look, he's an amazing musician, he's a kind and thoughtful person,” says Flea of the guitarist who replaced John Frusciante in 2009 and played on 2012's I'm With You and 2016's The Getaway.

Why is Frusciante rejoining RHCP? ›

Ultimately, Frusciante rejoined when he felt like he was in the right place to do so. “I found for myself that I needed to clear my head of it and find out who I am as a person. I really wanted to have that closeness and that kind of vulnerable interaction with them again.”

Who died in Red Hot Chili Peppers? ›

The Uplift Mofo Party Plan was released in 1987. However, after struggling with a heroin addiction for a number of years, Slovak died of an overdose on June 25, 1988 following the conclusion of the album's promotional tour.

When did John Frusciante get married? ›

Is under the bridge about drugs? ›

"Under the Bridge" is a song by the American rock band Red Hot Chili Peppers and the eleventh track on their fifth studio album, Blood Sugar Sex Magik (1991). Vocalist Anthony Kiedis wrote the lyrics while reflecting on loneliness and the struggles of being clean from drugs, and almost didn't share it with the band.

Why did Cliff Martinez leave RHCP? ›

Creative differences, however, led to his being fired by singer Anthony Kiedis and bassist Flea during the recording of their third album. They claimed his heart wasn't in it anymore. “I had been in the band for three years and it didn't appeal to me anymore,” he says.

How old is Flea? ›

Who is the richest Rhcp member? ›

And today in 2022, Red Hot Chili Peppers bassist Michael Peter Balzary's net worth seems to be $150, which makes him the richest member of the band.

How rich is Dave Grohl? ›

$320 million

Why is flea so rich? ›

Flea, who took part in every RHCP album that ever released, has a net worth of $150 million, which makes him the richest member of the band. Ranked as the second-best bassist of all time by Rolling Stone magazine, Flea has been known for his unique playing style consisted of funk, punk, hard rock, and psychedelic.

What guitars does John Frusciante play? ›

John Frusciante is best known for playing Fender Stratocaster guitars. He's also been associated with other guitars such as his Gretsch White Falcon. He has three Stratocasters in particular that are his most famous and prevalently used within live shows and in the studio.

Is Josh Klinghoffer in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? ›

Josh Klinghoffer was inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 2012 as a member of Red Hot Chili Peppers, but the guitarist has admitted he wasn't comfortable with the proceedings.

What RHCP albums did John Frusciante play? ›

Frusciante played on the Chili Peppers' breakthrough albums Mother's Milk in 1989 and 1991's Blood Sugar Sex Magik but was uncomfortable with being thrust into the spotlight due to the band's ever-growing success and walked away.

How old is Josh Klinghoffer? ›

Did RHCP leave Flea? ›

Red Hot Chili Peppers bassist Flea admits he wanted to leave the American funk group when guitarist John Frusciante quit the band for the second time. Red Hot Chili Peppers' Flea wanted to quit the band when John Frusciante left for a second time.

When did Dave Navarro leave RHCP? ›

After two years of touring on and off with Red Hot Chili Peppers, and his subsequent heroin relapse, Navarro was fired in 1998 over "creative differences".

How tall is Josh Klinghoffer? ›

What guitars do Pearl Jam use? ›

Guitars
  • - Gibson Les Paul Junior guitar (doublecut / blonde color, tortoise shell pickguard)
  • - 1956 Gibson Les Paul Black.
  • - 1956 and 1958 Fender Stratocasters with Sunburst Finish.
  • - 1958 Fender Stratocaster Sunburst Finish Left-handed Body. ...
  • - 1959 Fender Stratocaster White Finish.

Who plays keyboard for Pearl Jam in concert? ›

Kenneth E. "Boom" Gaspar (born February 3, 1953) is an American musician. He is best known for having performed with American rock band Pearl Jam as a keyboardist since 2002.

Who is playing guitar for Pearl Jam? ›

Michael David McCready (born April 5, 1966) is an American musician who serves as the lead guitarist for the American rock band Pearl Jam. Along with Jeff Ament, Stone Gossard, and Eddie Vedder, he is one of the founding members of the band.

Is John Frusciante in the Hall of Fame? ›

According to Red Hot Chili Peppers drummer Chad Smith, their April 14 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction will include former members of the band, however, erstwhile guitarist John Frusciante will not be one of them.

Why do they call him Flea? ›

From his early teens, Flea acquired the nickname 'Mikey B. The Flea' which then got shortened to Flea because of his fidgety nature and his inability to keep still. Some reports claim that Flea - who was born in Melbourne, Australia - was given the nickname by Kiedis while they were on a ski trip.

What does the RHCP symbol mean? ›

Meaning and history

According to RHCP, the eight-pronged asterisk does not have any symbolic meaning at all. Anthony Kiedis, the band's front man, claimed to be the author of both the idea and the initial sketch.

How rich is Mick Jagger? ›

According to Celebrity Net Worth, 78-year-old Mick Jagger has a net worth of $500million (around £413million).

How old is Justin Bieber net worth? ›

Justin Bieber Net Worth
Net Worth:$285 Million
Date of Birth:Mar 1, 1994 (28 years old)
Gender:Male
Height:5 ft 8 in (1.75 m)
Profession:Musician, Singer-songwriter, Actor, Record producer, Dancer, Singer
2 more rows

How rich is Steve Tyler? ›

Steven Tyler is an American rock musician who has a net worth of $150 million. He is most famous for being a founding member and lead singer for the band Aerosmith which is one of the most-successful bands of all time.

Is Jack Sherman really dead? ›

How many guitarists have RHCP had? ›

All told, the Red Hot Chili Peppers have had seven total guitarists in their history. Original axeman Hillel Slovak died of an overdose in 1988 and was followed by DeWayne McKnight, Frusciante, Arik Marshall, Dave Navarro and Frusciante again.

Does Frusciante play Josh Klinghoffer songs? ›

Frusciante has never played any of the band's songs with Navarro live, and he didn't play any Klinghoffer material at the band's recent return to the stage. Red Hot Chili Peppers are touring extensively in 2022.

How much money does John Frusciante make? ›

John Frusciante is an American guitarist, singer, songwriter and producer who has a net worth of $25 million. He is best known for being the guitarist of the rock band the Red Hot Chili Peppers.

Why is Frusciante rejoining RHCP? ›

Ultimately, Frusciante rejoined when he felt like he was in the right place to do so. “I found for myself that I needed to clear my head of it and find out who I am as a person. I really wanted to have that closeness and that kind of vulnerable interaction with them again.”

When did John Frusciante get married? ›

Why did Rhcp fire Josh? ›

The classic guitarist parted ways with the band for the second time after touring their Stadium Arcadium album and has since reunited with them, replacing Josh Klinghoffer in 2019. Now, speaking to Classic Rock, the Black Summer rocker has revealed he left the band over a decade ago due to being "off-balance mentally".

Who replaced John Frusciante? ›

Everybody loved Josh Klinghoffer, but it wasn't working out

“Look, he's an amazing musician, he's a kind and thoughtful person,” says Flea of the guitarist who replaced John Frusciante in 2009 and played on 2012's I'm With You and 2016's The Getaway.

Is Josh Klinghoffer in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? ›

Josh Klinghoffer was inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 2012 as a member of Red Hot Chili Peppers, but the guitarist has admitted he wasn't comfortable with the proceedings.

Who is the richest Rhcp member? ›

And today in 2022, Red Hot Chili Peppers bassist Michael Peter Balzary's net worth seems to be $150, which makes him the richest member of the band.

How rich is Dave Grohl? ›

$320 million

Who is the richest member of Red Hot Chili Peppers? ›

Anthony Kiedis Net Worth
Net Worth:$155 Million
Gender:Male
Height:5 ft 8 in (1.75 m)
Profession:Songwriter, Actor, Singer-songwriter, Lyricist, Musician
Nationality:United States of America
1 more row

Why did Frusciante leave? ›

Virtuoso guitarist John Frusciante left Red Hot Chili Peppers for the second time in 2009. He explained that he wasn't in the right place mentally, as he put it, he was an “imbalanced mess”. Thankfully, in 2019, Frusciante returned to the group after a ten-year break.

Is under the bridge about drugs? ›

"Under the Bridge" is a song by the American rock band Red Hot Chili Peppers and the eleventh track on their fifth studio album, Blood Sugar Sex Magik (1991). Vocalist Anthony Kiedis wrote the lyrics while reflecting on loneliness and the struggles of being clean from drugs, and almost didn't share it with the band.

What guitar does John Frusciante play? ›

John Frusciante is best known for playing Fender Stratocaster guitars. He's also been associated with other guitars such as his Gretsch White Falcon. He has three Stratocasters in particular that are his most famous and prevalently used within live shows and in the studio.

Is John Frusciante in the Hall of Fame? ›

According to Red Hot Chili Peppers drummer Chad Smith, their April 14 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction will include former members of the band, however, erstwhile guitarist John Frusciante will not be one of them.

Who is John Frusciante wife? ›

Is Frusciante married? ›

You might also like

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Lidia Grady

Last Updated: 08/29/2022

Views: 5952

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lidia Grady

Birthday: 1992-01-22

Address: Suite 493 356 Dale Fall, New Wanda, RI 52485

Phone: +29914464387516

Job: Customer Engineer

Hobby: Cryptography, Writing, Dowsing, Stand-up comedy, Calligraphy, Web surfing, Ghost hunting

Introduction: My name is Lidia Grady, I am a thankful, fine, glamorous, lucky, lively, pleasant, shiny person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.